Commenters were being rapid to defend a person expecting mom who stated why she known as her coworker a hypocrite in a well-liked online forum.
In a viral Reddit submit released on r/AmITheA**hole, Redditor u/Artistic_Probability_5077 (normally referred to as the original poster, or OP) mentioned that she and her spouse have deemed naming their daughter right after a Harry Potter character—something one particular of her coworkers vehemently disagreed with.
Titled, “AITA for calling my coworker a hypocrite for offering her infant a ‘nerdy’ name,” the viral write-up has been given much more than 8,000 votes and 1,500 opinions in the previous working day.
Producing that the pair has but to “lock in” a name for their baby just nevertheless, the first poster said they are leaning to Minerva, after Professor Minerva McGonagall from the fictional Hogwarts College of Witchcraft and Wizardry.
Even so, soon after speaking about the potential baby identify at get the job done, the first poster recounted the criticism she obtained from a coworker, referred to as Gwen.
“My coworkers and I were being talking about my future maternity depart when it obtained to names. I explained we hadn’t determined but like Minerva,” she wrote. “It really should be mentioned that it is a properly acknowledged truth in my office that I am a large Harry Potter enthusiast.”
“Gwen started interrupting me and telling me that I shouldn’t ‘force my fandom’ on my newborn by giving her a Harry Potter title,” she continued. “I get what she implies, but then I mentioned this: ‘Okay, but you named your daughter soon after Harley Quinn, ideal? Isn’t that the exact matter?'”
Conveying that Harley Quinn is a character inside the DC Comics Universe, the primary poster questioned why naming a toddler soon after one particular fictional character is suitable, even though naming a little one following a character from a separate fictional universe is not.
“I will not know what [Gwen] is like at dwelling, but naming your child just after a comics character is not improved than if it truly is from a further fandom?” she wrote.
Naming young children immediately after fictional characters is not a new phenomenon, and is not minimal to Harry Potter and DC Comics.
For yrs, mothers and fathers have bestowed the names of beloved kings, queens, mermaids, witches, wizards, Jedis and so many other main figures featured in tv collection, videos and books.
Two a long time in the past, Buzzfeed posted a listing of the 16 most preferred names derived from fictional figures.
Provided on the listing ended up Elsa (from Disney’s Frozen), Anakin (from Star Wars), Ariel (from Disney’s The Little Mermaid), Katniss (from The Starvation Video games) and Khaleesi (from Sport of Thrones), between other people.
In the case of Khaleesi, also regarded as Daenerys, Vulture described in 2019 that hundreds of infants were being born with equally monikers, and that Khaleesi, specifically, experienced turn out to be one of the 1,000 most popular toddler names during the 12 months prior.
Through the to start with seven seasons of Activity of Thrones, Khaleesi would have seemed like a valiant identify. But after the last time of HBO’s thrilling collection noticed the character transform into the bloodthirsty “Mad Queen,” the connotations involved with the name transformed fully.
In her viral Reddit article, the unique poster remained adamant that identify alternatives are parents’ to make, and that they need to be respected, regardless of the fictional universes they come from.
“If you identify your newborn right after a fictional character, then you shouldn’t criticize other people for doing the similar factor,” she wrote. “Even if you despise the other fandom.”
Redditors responding to the viral post echoed that sentiment.
“You happen to be [not the a**hole],” Redditor u/Fritemare assured the initial poster, in a comment that has received almost 4,000 votes.
“[Minerva] is an actual name. It was a title just before Harry Potter arrived together,” they continued. “It is really also tremendous hypocritical for them to call you out when they literally named their little ones soon after their fandoms.”
Redditor u/TahiniInMyVeins, whose remark has obtained practically 2,000 votes, responded straight to the viral post’s title, and said that the primary poster was justified to contact out her coworker.
“You did not criticize Gwen for naming her kid a ‘nerdy’ identify,” they wrote. “You criticized Gwen for staying a hypocrite.”
In the post’s leading comment, which has received a lot more than far more than 15,000 votes, Redditor u/waywardjynx relayed a related concept.
“[Not the a**hole],” they commented. “She ashamed herself.”